Explain why trotsky did not become the leader of the ussr after lenin’s death in 1924 the bolsheviks (although not out rightly stated) were in need of a new leader the power struggle occurred from 1923-1929 and eventually stalin effectively became the leader of the ussr due to many reasons, including the weaknesses of trotsky. In vladimir lenin's government in the russian revolution, leon trotsky first played the role of commissar for foreign affairs and then the leader of the red army in the bolshevik government, he was second only to lenin and seemed destined to succeed him until joseph stalin outmaneuvered him. Lenin did not like trotsky, but trotsky was so important that he was forced to work with him trotsky became chairman of the military revolutionary committee – ie leader of the bolshevik red guards as such, it was trotsky who organised the november revolution and carried it out. Stalin, trotsky and the struggle for power after lenin’s death introduction this activity was designed and used by sally burnham who teaches in peterborough it’s an excellent activity for a number of reasons and well-worth reading and thinking about even if you don’t teach russian history. Why did stalin become leader after lenin, not trotsky essay sample in the beginning, as lenin end grew nearer, there were five potential leaders, bukharin, kamenev, zinoviev, trotsky and stalin.
Rise of joseph stalin jump to in the years following, opponents of stalin, most notably leon trotsky, became isolated politically and were sidelined from the government by stalin eventually, this led stalin to become the uncontested highest leader of the party and the soviet union. Stalin was committed, hard working, and determined he did the jobs that others didnt, making him a cunning shadow in the background trotsky was aloof and dismissive, considered himself the only real contender he was so determind to stick to his policies it made people question his loyalty. However, he did not have a very good record when he had the power to make decisions the kronstadt sailors, who had played an important role in the russian revolution, became disillusioned with the bolshevik government.
The provisional government did not realise this, so they were only too pleased to get a decent army (the red guard) to defend the government from kornilov, who was a major threat to government. Stalin vs trotsky this is a reprint the great majority of the marxists in georgia became and stayed menshevik among the bolsheviks stalin was prominent, but that did not mean a great deal this assertion was difficult to explain on marxist grounds, unless it were to be on the basis of marx's analysis of oriental society, and the. -trotsky's idea of why stalin gained power is that it was all due to the failure of the international revolution and the isolation, which followed, which showed russia's backwardness and the political apathy of the working class. As part of your revision, think about the arguments and facts you would use to explain: how stalin came to power in communist russia in 1924 why stalin, and not trotsky, emerged as lenin's successor. Due to plekhanov's opposition, trotsky did not become a full member of the editorial board, but from that point on he participated in its meetings in an advisory capacity, which earned him plekhanov's enmity.
In 1918, he became war commissioner and set about building up the red army, which succeeded in defeating anti-communist opposition in the russian civil war in the early 1920s, trotsky seemed the. Discuss at least three reasons why trotsky did not assume the party leadership 10 explain joseph stalin’s career and contribution to the revolution up to and including 1922. With trotsky already being unpopular stalin tricked him to not turning up to lenin’s funeral this not only put a terrible light upon trotsky, stalin was able to play a huge role in the procession portraying himself as lenin’s disciple, wanting to carry on the work of lenin.
Explain why trotsky did not become the leader of the ussr after lenin’s death in 1924 the bolsheviks (although not out rightly stated) were in need of a new leader. Trotsky's idea that the revolution could not be sustained in conservative europe and had to keep expanding was not as appealing as stalin's 'socialism in one country' michael lynch's book on trotsky is a good place to start. Leon trotsky was born lev davidovich bronstein in yanovka, ukraine—in the russian empire—on november 7, 1879 his parents, david and anna bronstein, were prosperous jewish farmers.
Published: mon, 5 dec 2016 the purpose of this paper is to examine how stalin became the sole leader of the soviet union while he was regarded to the politburo as a minor player who had no chance of defeating trotsky. Page 24 13 tucker, page 324 14 ward, page 16 15 tucker, page 313 16 daniels, page 236 nick surry hiliary 2013: fs30 potential and act according to the tentative situation, stalin did not fail in this, and this is arguably one of the fundamental reasons why trotsky fell victim to the stalin’s political cunning. Trotsky was born in the ukraine in 1879, the son of a prosperous farmer he was given the name lev bronstein, after an uncle who had unsuccessfully attempted to assassinate alexander ii (there was a revolutionary streak in his family as there had been in lenin’s. Thank you for your response i'm not sure i understand your first point about no one being left to rehabilitate him - please explain i understand why general secretaries after stalin wouldn't push for trotsky's rehabilitation.